As a kid, I used to tell my brother scary takes of the madwoman in the attic and we used to huddle under our attic trapdoor in shivering delightful fear, so I suppose the story of Bertha in Jane Eyre has always been of interest. I've known OF this book, but have never read it until now. I think giving a voice and a backstory to Bertha is a fairly brilliant idea, and the postmodern, feminist interpretation this novel offers is both startlingly complex, and poetically simple.
A short read, but not, I think, an easy one. I'm not sure how well readers unfamiliar with Jane Eyre will understand the plot, though the deep psychological aspects are well done and unsettling even without context. Some of the language is beautifully rendered and the imagery is evocative of both time and place, and an ironic sense of being in a dream.
I found myself pausing to investigate Creole history in the first section, and enjoying the descriptive details. The second section gave insight into her husband....and I admit I wasn't wholly sold on their relationship, and her descent into madness...but I found the name change to Bertha both powerful and horrifying. The final section, short and direct, offered explanation and perhaps a sense of forgiveness for the woman whose final act leads to the culmination of one of the classic novels of the 19th century.
We have been talking....I have been ranting....about how Jane Eyre is thematically a 19th century version of 50 Shades. Much better written, I grant, but when I re-read Jane Eyre last year, I was horrified to discover how different it was than what I remember. Gone was Rochester as romantic hero. In his place was a lying, manipulative, demanding wealthy man who bullied and abused the innocent servant girl in his employ. I mean yeah, context of its time and all that, but essentially an imbalance of power. So reading Wide Sargasso Sea came at the right time for me.
PS: I still like Jane Eyre. And Wuthering Heights. But Rochester? Heathcliffe? How could I have been so wrong about them all these years?
PPS: Erik enjoying the used bookstore (see below).
2 comments:
I had a similar experience with a movie recently - I'd remembered The American President as cute and funny and romantic, and so when I had a need for a little bit of curl-up-on-the-couch time I bought it on iTunes, on the assumption that I'd be watching it again. I was thoroughly horrified (and a little depressed) by the power imbalance, and the way Andy (the president) worked this. Anything less than the simpering cutest-compliance of the Annette Benning character and this would have been a stalker-thriller. Eek - what was I thinking?
I read Jane Eyre for the first time just a couple of years ago. I don't remember all of it, but I do remember having more or less the same response to the same relationship. Different time? I'm older? I wonder what I would have thought if I'd read it a couple of decades ago instead?
I also wonder if I remember enough of JE to enjoy Wide Sargasso Sea (did we even know about a Caribbean connection in JE? I didn't remember that either, although it's starting to sound familiar). I'm intrigued, but I don't particularly want to re-read Jane Eyre.
Haha, Sasha. Yes, I think I would notice that more now than before.
Post a Comment